When Meredith Whitney ominously warned of new dangers in the municipal bonds markets, she was only reiterating in forceful language what many analysts have been aware of for years. Traditionally, municipal bonds have been one of the safest investments for conservative buyers and historically they have lower default rates than corporate bonds. However, Ms. Whitney upped the ante by suggesting that as many as 50–100 “sizeable” defaults could occur within the coming months, representing hundreds of millions of dollars.
Against the larger total of $3 trillion dollars in outstanding municipal debt, this may not seem like a huge percentage, but to each individual investor and municipal bond holder, such losses could be crushing. Also, when unhealthy counties, cities, public agencies or utilities default, the damage can leak over onto healthy economies. Is Ms. Whitney correct in predicting calamity in the near future in municipal bonds? While her detractors are numerous and loud, men such as Warren Buffett and Jamie Dimon, CEO of JP Morgan tend to agree. Dimon expects more US municipalities to file for bankruptcy and warns, “If you are an investor in municipals you should be very, very careful.”
With prices falling and investors leaving the muni bonds market by the droves, especially since Ms. Whitney’s public announcements, the broader question becomes why are so many state and local governments in danger of defaulting? It would appear that several factors are at work and both timing and dangerous fiscal policy from the top down have played a significant role in the precarious positions states such as New York, California, New Jersey and Illinois now find themselves.
Everyone agrees that the Recession did a lot of damage as more homes were lost to foreclosure and jobs disappeared or were falsely created by agencies that couldn’t afford them as part of government stimulus acceptance requirements aimed at assisting women and minorities. In spite of reduced revenue from devalued properties, bankruptcies and lost jobs, in many places local spending continued unabated. Additionally those adversely affected were requiring more and more community assistance in the form of social services.
Incentive programs such as the Build America Bonds strategy only encouraged epidemic borrowing now to pay later, the equivalent of “generational robbery” in which localities “borrow from the future dollars to benefit the present,” according to Ms. Whitney. Now many cities and states are saddled with enormous debt loads and scarce resources with which to meet them. California, land of fantasy, faces a $19 billion budget deficit; New Jersey has cut services 26% and still holds a $10 billion debt; Illinois is six months behind paying $5 billion in outstanding debts; Miami is facing bankruptcy; Detroit is suggesting a 20% cut in essential social services; and Arizona actually sold its capitol building, supreme court building and legislative space in a desperate attempt to rein in debt loads. Organ transplants for Medicaid patients were also on the axe list.
The reality is that the majority of state and local governments, while feeling the pinch, are coping with more stringent policies, slashing where necessary, but maintaining a diet that will make them lean without starving them to death. States like Texas have found ways to cut spending in less critical areas, and while it still hurts, the procedures seem to be working. The old-fashioned, conservative policy of only spending what you have available and not borrowing against future expected income may be an inconvenient and expensive lesson to learn. However, unless we want to shackle our children and grandchildren with unconquerable debt, the time for refusing costly government handouts and fiscal belt-tightening is certainly here.
From a stock broker perspective or for online trading investors, muni bonds are as healthy as the agency offering them. During the last half of 2010, they rose in profit rapidly and substantially. Most state and local governments are not at risk of default and there are still good deals to be made. However, as Jamie Dimon warned, be careful, very careful.